Comprehensive Refutation of Abdullāh Hāshim Abā al-Ṣādiq Claims in "Imam Mahdi Appeared (Part 3)"
Refuting the assertions made by Abdullāh Hāshim Abā al-Ṣādiq from the YouTube video titled "Imam Mahdi Appeared (Part 3)" necessitates a meticulous examination grounded in authentic Islamic sources, including the Qur'an, Hadith (Prophetic traditions), and established scholarly interpretations. The statements presented by Abdull?h H?shim Ab? al-??diq address the criteria for recognizing true messengers, the irrelevance of outward appearance in determining prophethood, and the reliability of moral conduct as a sole indicator of divine appointment. This comprehensive refutation delves into each of these points, demonstrating how they contradict core Islamic doctrines.16.3 Imam Mahdi Appeared (Part 3)
1. Claim: God's Plan Is Changeable and Adaptable
Abdullāh Hāshim Abā al-Ṣādiq:
"It's like all things are changeable in the plan of God and adaptable to the circumstances..."
Islamic Perspective:
The claim that God's plan is changeable contradicts the fundamental Islamic belief in Qadar (Divine Decree). Allah's knowledge and will encompass all creation and events, and nothing occurs without His eternal knowledge.
Qur'an Reference:إن كل شيء خلقناه بقدر.
"Indeed, all things We created with predestination."
📔 - (Surah Al-Qamar 54:49)Scholarly Commentary: Ibn Kathir explains that this verse affirms that Allah’s decree is eternal and unchanging. Suggesting that God's plan changes undermines His omniscience and sovereignty.
Refutation: The belief that God's plan changes is a false interpretation. While human perceptions of events may differ, Allah’s plan remains perfect and unaltered.2. Claim: Prophets Cannot Be Judged by Their Actions or Morals
Abdullāh Hāshim Abā al-Ṣādiq:
"...you cannot deny him because of health reasons like in the case of Job... or judge whether or not a person is a proof of God... based on his apparent actions or behavior or morals and manners..."
Islamic Perspective:
Prophets are chosen by Allah and are sinless (Ma'soom). Their actions, morals, and manners serve as models for humanity.
Qur'an Reference:
لقد كان لكم في رسول الله أسوة حسنة لمن كان يرجو الله واليوم الآخر وذكر الله كثيرا
"Indeed in the Messenger of Allah (Muhammad) you have an excellent example for whoever has hope in Allah and the Last Day and remembers Allah often."
📔 - (Surah Al-Ahzab 33:21)Hadith Reference: The Prophet Muhammad ? said:
إن خياركم هو أحسنكم أخلاقا و خلقا
"The best of you are those who have the best manners and character."
📔 - (Sahih Bukhari, Hadith 3559)Refutation: While Allah may test Prophets like Job (Ayyub) with illnesses or hardships, their moral integrity, behavior, and adherence to divine commands are crucial signs of their prophethood. The claim that their morals or actions are irrelevant contradicts Islamic principles.
3. Misrepresentation of Noah's Story
Abdullāh Hāshim Abā al-Ṣādiq:
"Noah was several times knocked upside the head, unconscious for several days, laying on the ground with blood flowing from his ears..."
Islamic Perspective:The Qur'an describes Prophet Noah (Nuh) as a steadfast and patient messenger, but the narrative of him being physically incapacitated or planting palm trees is not supported by the Qur'an or authentic Hadith. Qur'an Reference:
لقد أرسلنا نوحا إلى قومه أن أنذر قومك من قبل أن يأتيهم عذاب أليم.
"Indeed, We sent Noah to his people, [saying], 'Warn your people before there comes to them a painful punishment.'"
📔 - (Surah Nuh 71:1)Refutation: The story of Noah planting a palm tree and waiting for its growth is not mentioned in Islamic sources. Adding unauthenticated details to prophetic stories misrepresents the teachings of Islam.
4. Claim: God's Promise Can Change
Abdullāh Hāshim Abā al-Ṣādiq:
"...even if God's promise changed..."
Islamic Perspective:
Allah's promises are absolute and never change.
Qur'an Reference:
وتمت كلمة ربك صدقا وعدلا. لا يستطيع أحد أن يبدل كلماته وهو السميع العليم
"And the word of your Lord has been fulfilled in truth and in justice. None can alter His words, and He is the Hearing, the Knowing."
📔 - (Surah Al-An’am 6:115)Hadith Reference: The Prophet Muhammad ? said:
"Verily, Allah does not break His promise."(Sahih Bukhari, Hadith 7505)
Refutation: The claim that Allah's promise can change directly contradicts explicit Quranic verses and authentic Hadith. This assertion undermines the perfection of Allah’s attributes.
5. Misinterpretation of Jesus’ Story
Abdullāh Hāshim Abā al-Ṣādiq:
"...Jesus is arrested. His body is crucified. He's killed in the apparent, in front of all of his believers..."
Islamic Perspective: Islam categorically denies the crucifixion and death of Jesus (Isa). Instead, Allah raised him to the heavens.
Qur'an Reference:
ولم يقتلوه ولم يصلبوه؛ ولكن [آخر] جعل يشبهه لهم. وإن الذين اختلفوا فيه لفي شك منه. وما لهم به من علم إلا اتباع الظن. ولم يقتلوه يقينا. بل رفعه الله إليه. وكان الله عزيزا حكيما.
"And they did not kill him, nor did they crucify him; but [another] was made to resemble him to them. And indeed, those who differ over it are in doubt about it. They have no knowledge of it except the following of assumption. And they did not kill him, for certain. Rather, Allah raised him to Himself. And ever is Allah Exalted in Might and Wise."
📔 - (Surah An-Nisa 4:157-158)Refutation: The claim that Jesus was crucified contradicts the Qur'an. Islamic teachings affirm that Allah protected Jesus from crucifixion, and he will return before the Day of Judgment.
6. Use of False Analogies
"Even all of Jesus' miracles that he performed was not sufficient as a way to make the people know whether or not he was truthful or not truthful." (14:35)
Abdullāh Hāshim Abā al-Ṣādiq:
"Even all of Jesus' miracles that he performed was not sufficient as a way to make the people know whether or not he was truthful or not truthful."
Islamic Perspective:
Miracles (Mu'jizat) are a clear proof of the truthfulness of Prophets.
Qur'an Reference:ولقد آتينا عيسى ابن مريم البينات وأيدناه بروح القدس.
"And We gave Jesus, the son of Mary, clear proofs and supported him with the Holy Spirit."
📔 - (Surah Al-Baqarah 2:87)Conclusion
Abdullāh Hāshim Abā al-Ṣādiq statements are riddled with inaccuracies and contradictions to Islamic teachings. By selectively using prophetic stories and adding unauthenticated details, he misrepresents Islamic principles. Muslims should rely on the Qur'an, authentic Hadith, and scholarly consensus to avoid such deviations.
Key References:- Qur'an (Surah Al-An’am 6:115, Surah An-Nisa 4:157-158, Surah Al-Qamar 54:49)
- Hadith Collections (Sahih Bukhari, Sahih Muslim)
- Tafsir Ibn Kathir
This refutation demonstrates the fallacies in the arguments presented and reinforces the authentic Islamic narrative.